No, I don't normally review movies. My schtick is that I compare two things, name one as the poor man's version and then move on with my day, but I took the Poor Woman to see
Superman Returns yesterday (in IMAX 3D, no less), and I feel compelled to talk about it.
So...
Superman Returns...well, I really liked it. Why?
I didn't think.
I was amazed how easy it was to stop thinking. The moment I shut down my brain, the rest of our glorious country started making sense.
American Idol made sense. Magazines hanging on everything 19-year-old rich girls say and do made sense.
Arrested Development getting cancelled made sense. My bank account made sense. Never in my wildest dreams did I ever think that not thinking could make sense of this world, but then here we are.
Which is not to say
Superman Returns is bad. Not in the slightest.
The 1978 movie is my touchstone, so let me start with where I feel they got it right with this one. Huzzah to the art direction team for honoring the look of that film, then tweaking it just enough to put their own stamp on things. Also, good call in not straying too far from John Williams' score. You made my inner 7-year-old very happy.
Brandon Routh - wow. I wasn't expecting to like him as much as I did, but once again: here we are. I think most people got it wrong when they said he looks just like Christopher Reeve, because he doesn't. However, he does
sound exactly like him (as both Clark & Superman), and in that one way captured the essence of his predecessor. Reeve nailed it the first time around, and Routh channels him without resorting to imitation. Bully for you, Brandon!
I was lukewarm to just about everything else.
Plot - The whole land thing is unimportant. Luthor's plan should've been more dangerous. I don't know what, but remember: I wasn't thinking, so I didn't care. If I was thinking then I would've thought it odd that Jimmy Olsen must've been an ace 13-year-old photographer with the Daily Planet when Superman left. That's what thinking will do to ya.
Kevin Spacey - If he had crossed his characters from
The Ref and
Se7en, then he might have been an interesting Luthor. Otherwise, so what?
Kate Bosworth - She was just fine as Lois, so quit giving her grief. Margot Kidder didn't exactly set the bar high in '78.
Parker Posey - So if Kitty is replacing Miss Teschmacher, what happened to Otis?
Sam Huntington - Nice Jimmy Olsen. Just geeky enough without being annoying. I liked him.
An observationThere seemed to be a lot of close-ups of objects shaking and vibrating on tables.
A questionWas Lois' kid ever going to smile, or did Bryan Singer inject botox into the actor's mouth?
Final thoughtsI left this movie feeling pretty close to the way I felt when I saw the 1978 flick. That is to say, I had some of that giddy, buzzing joy of just being in another world. The movie had some magic to it, and I went along gladly. I'm older now, so I wasn't running out of the theater telling everyone I could fly, but I was happier for the experience. George Lucas could learn a thing or two from Bryan Singer about how not to royally screw up my childhood movie memories.
What the hell are they gonna do for a sequel? Clearly, this movie favored action over camp (but still struck a nice balance), so what villain can they bring in next to challenge Superman without resorting to laughs? Bizarro? Mr. Mxyzptlk ? My guess is they'll go with Brainiac. Also, the one thing that's missing in all Superman movies is the knock-down, drag-out fight. I don't think Superman knows how to fight because he's only had to lift and catch heavy things his entire life. No one can ever challenge him to fisticuffs. He's freakin' Superman.
Whoops. I started thinking. Bad idea.
In conclusion: good movie. Well worth the time spent. Curious to see what happens next.
P.S. The 3D was pointless. 30 seconds of the 20 minutes of 3D footage looked great. And the glasses/headgear was ridiculous.